351 Plymouth Street

Taxes: $13,263 (2026)

About this home

Own a rare piece of local 19th Century history with this iconic historical home custom built for P.T. Barnum entertainer, General Tom Thumb. Sitting in front of 114 acres of conservation land, with its distinctive Mansard roof, this nearly 4761 square foot Victorian is full of architectural character throughout, where 10 foot ceilings, exquisite original plasterwork, oversized hardwood doors, ornate hand turned railings and balusters, built ins, crown moldings, ceiling medallions and custom wall alcoves showcase craftsmanship rarely found today. A striking main staircase anchors the home, while a separate original servant staircase connects its four finished levels and offers a fascinating glimpse into the home's history. Thoughtfully updated over the years, the home blends historic character with modern comfort. The renovated chef's kitchen features custom cabinetry, high end appliances including a Viking gas stove and oven, and dramatic brick archways opening to the family room. A working dumbwaiter connects to the dining room and butler's pantry, while the original lower height stove is another unique reminder of the home's past. With 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bedrooms including a spacious primary suite, multiple gathering spaces, gas heating and central air, this property is as functional as it is nostalgic. Outside, the nearly 1.5 acre property was designed for entertaining. The fenced grounds feature an oversized in-ground pool, expansive patio, and a pool house with kitchenette and bath offering exciting potential for future ADU use, subject to buyer due diligence and required approvals. A separate cabana with built-in grill and Italian brick oven creates another destination for outdoor gatherings, while an awesome garden shed adds charm and useful storage. A heated and insulated three car garage provides abundant parking and storage. Rich in history, architectural detail and scale, the Tom Thumb House offers the rare opportunity to own a home with a story unlike any other, while still enjoying the space, amenities and comfort today's lifestyle demands.

Property details

Sewer

On-Site

Style

Antique

Water

City/Town Water

Cooling

Central Air

Heating

Forced Air, Electric Baseboard, Central Heat, Hot Air Gravity

Type

Detached

Flooring

Wood, Tile, Wall to Wall Carpet, Other (See Remarks)

Road type

Public

Appliances

Range, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer, Vent Hood

Master Bath

Yes

Construction

Aluminum

Roof

Aluminum

Garage

Detached, Garage Door Opener, Heated

Lot

Fenced/Enclosed, Level

Parking

1-10 Spaces, Stone/Gravel

Basement

Full, Finished, Walk Out, Interior Access, Exterior Access

Electric

200 Amps

Exterior

Porch, Pool - Inground, Gutters, Storage Shed, Screens, Fenced Yard, Gazebo, Guest House