17 Indian Trail

Taxes: $74,701 (2025)

About this home

A secluded treasure nestled on a private island. In the 1950s, Paul Mellon, heir to the famous banking family that established the National Gallery of Art in Washington D.C., and his wife Bunny chose this setting for a summer retreat. They created a home of elegance, comfort and great beauty, where they entertained world leaders, movie stars and industrialists. Bunny shaped the gardens and landscape, creating an exquisite blend of native plantings and trees. The 7,300-square-foot main house is integrated into the land, with its eight bedrooms offering views of either the sea or the gardens. Natural pathways wind through the property, connecting the main house to cottages—including a former art studio converted into a private suite—and lead to a beach house, where the Mellons hosted President John F. Kennedy and Jacqueline. With over 500 feet of waterfront, a private dock, and access to a private island, now serving as a protected bird sanctuary, this is an island haven like no other.

Property details

Sewer

On-Site

Style

Other (See Remarks)

Water

City/Town Water

Cooling

Central Air

Heating

Individual

Type

Detached

Flooring

Hardwood

Waterfront

Sound, River

Garage

Detached

Lot

Flood Plain, Scenic View(s)

Exterior

Patio, Covered Patio/Deck, Tennis Court, Storage Shed, Greenhouse, Professional Landscaping, Stone Wall

Interior

Security System, Wetbar

Waterview Features

River, Sound